Vegans of Color

Because we don’t have the luxury of being single-issue

Exotic to whom? November 3, 2007

Filed under: Uncategorized — johanna @ 10:18 am
Tags: , , , ,

A few years ago, there was an article in a veg magazine that was called “Exotic Produce 101.” I think it was meant to be part of a series; anyway, the one I saw focused on Asian produce. Apparently, “[f]or your family and friends, [Asian] greens are exotic enough to be interesting but familiar enough not to be scary.”

Let’s unpack the assumptions in that sentence. First of all, the assumption that whoever is reading this is unfamiliar with Asian vegetables — & thus is probably not Asian. Second of all, that “exotic” equals “interesting.” And also, that while “exotic” is good, too exotic is bad, Other, frightening.

Now I know that vegans pride themselves on the wide variety of food they cook & eat. Me too; I’ve long thought that veg*ns (especially vegans) eat a more varied diet than omnivores. And I like to learn about new cuisines to try too. But sometimes it starts to feel a little colonial, a little imperialist, you know what I mean? Calling the article “Produce from Around the World,” for example, would’ve been a lot less loaded than “Exotic Produce 101.” If we are what we eat, what does this imply for folks for whom this “exotic” produce is normal? Are we exotic & exciting & Other, too? Are we to be coveted for our ability to spice up your (white) life? (Oh yeah, I forgot: that’s how it works. Gwen Stefani wearing a bindi = cool. People who wear bindis because it is part of their cultural background & tradition are “too ethnic” & get targeted by people like the Dotbusters gang.)

Related to this, I mentioned online that one thing I wish I could find a really good vegan substitute for was bi bim bap — the vegetarian kind that has a fried egg in it. A few people mentioned that they had no idea what food I was even talking about. Okay, I’m not Korean, but I am Asian, & I have friends who are Korean & w/whom I’ve eaten bi bim bap. For me, it’s part of my cultural experience of being Asian. I could’ve substituted in pancit or lumpia from my own cultural tradition (both of which are easier to veganize, but let’s just use that as an example) & probably would’ve received the same bewilderment. Sure, there are probably lots of vegans who know what all these foods are (some of them are probably even Asian too). But because the only response I received was puzzlement, I feel safe assuming that there are many vegans who don’t. It felt kind of lonely. If I had said, “I want a really convincing mac & cheese recipe!” I don’t think anyone in the thread would’ve had trouble understanding what I was looking for.

Oyceter writes here about common & hidden cultural knowledge (Coffeeandink has a round-up of responses here). She says:

Your holidays, the ones that you travel miles away to celebrate, are always the ones people forget about. Your history, the one where you trace back where your ancestors came from, is never taught in class. You have to explain what you’re eating. You have to sit there and feel dumb that you don’t get a reference when everyone else in the room does, or face their disbelief when you say that you don’t get it. But when you mention something from your culture, everyone shuts up and doesn’t know what to say, since they don’t know what it is.

It’s not people denying you a job or refusing a loan, but it’s still isolating and painful. And it can be a little thing, like a non-knitter sitting with knitters. But the non-knitter can go back to non-knitter society pretty darn fast (ha! darn! get it? ok-i’ll-go-away-now).

Yeah. Vegans feel alienated from mainstream society a lot. And some vegans feel further alienated by vegan society, y’know?


7 Responses to “Exotic to whom?”

  1. pattricejones Says:

    Thanks for unpacking “exotic,” the problematic uses of which most white people seem not to see, despite the ethnocentricity built into the word (“exo” = outer, assuming that people like the user of the term are central).

    And, of course, the term is just supposed to mean “from elsewhere” but is implicitly raced and somewhat eroticized in actual practice. I suspect that magazine would not call the Scottish dish haggis (a pudding made of minced organ meat mixed with suet and oatmeal) “exotic,” even though it’s readers would be much less likely to encounter it than, say, bok choy.

    By the way, I do know somebody who claims to make a vegan version of bi bim bop. I’m skeptical myself, given the centrality of the egg to the dish, but I’ll try to get the recipe.

    And… Welcome to the blogosphere! I’m looking forward to reading this blog regularly.

  2. vegansofcolor Says:

    Pattrice–thanks for your comment! You raise a very good point about haggis. Even though it might be seen as unusual & strange & weird to some vegans, yeah, I don’t think it’d be called exotic.

    If you do manage to find that bi bim bap recipe I’d love to see it–I’m skeptical too, but curious!

    Thanks for posting about your NYU event last week. I really wanted to go but ended up both w/a conflict & feeling sick (hope your cold is better too!).

  3. chaia Says:

    Hey, thanks for the link from the LJ SNR comm- I keep my real-life name off LiveJournal, but use it on the ExtendingFamily blog that I linked to right here. I have passed your url along to the friend I mentioned earlier, and have added this to my blogroll. I look forward to reading more! xoxo.

  4. vegansofcolor Says:

    Chaia–thanks so much for your comment! Sorry for the slow reply, I’ve been out of town & am still a bit jet-lagged & catching up w/things. I’m definitely going to check out your friend’s LJ that you mentioned. Also your blog looks really interesting–creating our own nontraditional family structures is something I find really important & interesting (& wish I could do more of).


  5. […] Tags: culture, food, indian, south asian, white privilege Back near the beginning of this blog, I wrote about how Vegetarian Journal exotified Asian foods & seemed, in doing so, to be writing from a […]

  6. […] by people of those cultures (& other people, of course, some of whom clearly can’t resist the exotic). I’ve also seen people talking about decolonizing diets that were not originally chock full […]

  7. […] 2010 Filed under: Uncategorized — johanna @ 7:32 am Tags: exotification I’ve written before about exotification in discussions around vegan food, but it’s something I’m always […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s