Vegans of Color

Because we don’t have the luxury of being single-issue

reflections on Elysia chlorotica January 15, 2010

Filed under: Uncategorized — Royce @ 4:20 pm
Tags: , ,

Animal or Vegetable

Earlier today I read an article about a slug discovered that possibly produces chlorophyll. I posted it to my facebook, and sort of forgot about it. It was interesting to me, but not mind blowing: it just sort of fit in with the ways I’ve figured that nature worked, that is not fitting into simple reified categories.

Then Elaine posted on Vegan Soapbox about this slug with links to posts I have written about species being socially constructed, and the potentiality of trans-speciality. Now I’m looking at this creature again and several things are crossing my mind.

1. This thing lives along the Atlantic seaboard. I’ve been potentially co-existing with these things my entire life.

2. This slug isn’t trans-special, its species is Elysia chlorotica. They are amazing for a different reason.

3. To say that this animal is part plant is, I think, as dishonest as saying a sundew or venus flytrap is part animal. It was at least an animal first, regardless of what one would want to call it now.

4. Ever read Top Secret? It’s about a boy who becomes part plant in a science fair experiment where he consumes massive amounts of magnesium to try and convert hemoglobin into chlorophyll? I read it when I was seven and loved it. (The edition I read had a much cooler cover than the one on Amazon–it showed the boy with leaves coming off of his body and his skin turning green).

5. Could I one day produce chlorophyll? When will science do that? I’ve often done the collective daydreaming game when someone mentions how cool it would be to be part plant. Though as fantastic as that would be I would rather be part fungi, and not be dependent on the sun.

6. Black Tom Cassidy after being shot by Cable = plant powers. Any other X-Men fans?

Lost his sanity though

7. The idea of this slug showing that the branches-of-the-tree-of-life aren’t the most adequate metaphor for evolution. Perhaps a paradigm shift to a view of evolution as a series of networks?

8. The slugs developed this ability possibly by ingesting photosynthetic algae. Algae aren’t plants. But I guess a headline of “Green Slug Discovered to be Part Animal, Part Eukaryote” doesn’t have the same ring.

9. Why are the only people I’ve heard talking about this vegan? We love talking about animals, mix in some photosynthesis and we are all over it.

10.

About these ads
 

6 Responses to “reflections on Elysia chlorotica”

  1. You said:
    “To say that this animal is part plant is, I think, as dishonest as saying a sundew or venus flytrap is part animal. It was at least an animal first, regardless of what one would want to call it now.”

    I agree. It’s an animal that has a plant-like adaptation.

    • To add to my last post, this animal doesn’t produce chlorophyll themself, but uses chloroplasts from the algae they eat. According to Wikipedia, this phenomenon is known as kleptoplasty.

  2. oc.kuewa Says:

    “7. The idea of this slug showing that the branches-of-the-tree-of-life aren’t the most adequate metaphor for evolution. Perhaps a paradigm shift to a view of evolution as a series of networks?”

    How about rhizomes? From Wiki (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhizome_%28philosophy%29)

    “Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari used the term “rhizome” to describe theory and research that allows for multiple, non-hierarchical entry and exit points in data representation and interpretation.”

  3. Doris Says:

    The ability to produce chorophyll is not what distinguishes a plant from an animal. The slugs can’t be plants because plant cells have cell walls in addition to cell membranes. Animal cells have only cell membranes.

  4. Marcus Says:

    “To say that this animal is part plant is, I think, as dishonest as saying a sundew or venus flytrap is part animal. It was at least an animal first, regardless of what one would want to call it now.”

    Actualli it is part plant – they found some plant genes in them the chloroplast need to surwife, the mainpart are still animal but there are genetical parts of plants!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 303 other followers